When expertise outpaces regulation, with Ryan Stein

Self-driving vehicles are only one instance of expertise outpacing regulation. Ryan Stein, from Insurance coverage Bureau of Canada, explains why insurers needs to be extra proactive with new expertise.


  • An Insurance coverage Bureau of Canada (IBC) survey discovered that most individuals understand self-driving vehicles to be safer than typical vehicles.
  • Insurers ought to play an lively position to interact governments and regulators as new applied sciences, like self-driving vehicles, turn out to be extra prevalent.
  • As regulators, insurers and governments look to replace legal guidelines to accommodate new applied sciences and tendencies, their tenet needs to be to ensure injured events have entry to fast and truthful compensation.

Self-driving vehicles and what occurs when regulation lags expertise, with Ryan Stein

Welcome again to the Accenture Insurance coverage Influencers podcast, the place we ask a few of the business’s foremost thinkers what the way forward for insurance coverage appears like. How may synthetic intelligence (AI), innovation and anti-fraud expertise change the business? Our first visitor is Ryan Stein, the chief director of auto insurance coverage coverage and innovation at Insurance coverage Bureau of Canada (IBC).

To date on this sequence, Ryan has talked about how self-driving vehicles pose a problem to right now’s auto insurance coverage rules, and why IBC recommends a single insurance coverage coverage to cowl each typical and automatic automobiles. On this episode, we take a look at the adoption of automated automobiles and basic ideas as insurers, governments and regulators attempt to preserve tempo with rising applied sciences.

The next transcript has been edited for size and readability.

For those who take a look at the analysis, automated automobiles are a lot safer than human drivers. On the identical time, lots of people are uncomfortable with the thought of robots behind the wheel. So what does adoption of automated automobiles appear to be sooner or later?

An IBC survey regarded on the total inhabitants and most of the people mentioned they weren’t desirous about driving an automatic car. However in case you checked out folks aged 18 to 34, most of them had been. And total most individuals understand these automobiles to be safer.

So when you do hear of individuals being hesitant to make use of this expertise, I feel the potential for automated automobiles is large. They may ultimately turn out to be nearly all of new car gross sales––I don’t know what number of tens of years that can take, however little doubt automated automobiles are coming and so they’re going to be on our on our roads. That’s why it’s so vital to guarantee that the auto insurance coverage legal guidelines are up to date, in order that insurance coverage corporations can supply the kind of protection that’s applicable for these automobiles.

And we expect that the single insurance coverage coverage—that can present protection no matter whether or not the human or the expertise triggered the collision—is the best way to go. And that it’s probably the most applicable approach of reaching what we expect is a crucial aim, which is ensuring that people who find themselves injured get entry to truthful and fast compensation.

I think about that’s significantly difficult in North America the place’s a patchwork of provincial or state legal guidelines governing auto insurance coverage to start with, and automatic automobiles particularly. To what extent is a nationwide technique vital so far as laws and regulation on this space?

If you may get all of the provinces to replace their insurance coverage legal guidelines on the identical time, that might be unbelievable. That may imply all Canadians, once they use or purchase automated automobiles, will be capable to get applicable insurance coverage.

Whereas it will be nice if this might all occur directly, that’s simply not how insurance coverage tends to work. It’s normally one province makes a change, kind of like what occurred with the sharing financial system. Ontario and Alberta did it first, updating their legal guidelines to accommodate journey sharing. And for automated automobiles it could possibly be the identical factor. If a few provinces are able to replace their legal guidelines to mirror car automation then they need to transfer. After which when the others are prepared, they will do the identical.

To what extent ought to insurers be taking part in a extra proactive position? Ought to they be guiding this public coverage and informing the regulation and having a seat at that desk as these legal guidelines are made?

The insurance coverage business has been fairly proactive. It was IBC’s member corporations that mentioned, “We’ve bought to have a look at this challenge.” And that led to growing the single-policy concept and the totally different options that supported it, the data-sharing association and all that, which led to the paper that we launched final yr.

The business has offered on the concepts on this paper to authorities regulator audiences throughout the nation, and has made it clear to the varied governments that we need to work with them on this. And the response from the provinces we’ve met with has been fairly optimistic.

That’s nice. IBC is concentrated on the Canadian market, however Canada isn’t the one nation to be grappling with the problem of automated automobiles. So what basic ideas ought to regulators, insurers and governments have in mind as they do look to replace legal guidelines to accommodate automated automobiles?

I feel the primary factor—and it’s the one which we actually centered on is—is that it’s vital to guarantee that people who find themselves injured have entry to fast and truthful compensation. That’s why auto insurance coverage is regulated.

After we had been working with our members and how automated automobiles would work within the current auto insurance coverage laws and regulation, we noticed a danger of individuals not with the ability to get truthful and fast compensation––of individuals being caught in expensive and protracted product legal responsibility litigation.

As soon as we recognized it’s vital that individuals have entry to truthful and fast compensation, we requested, how can we replace the insurance coverage legal guidelines to make that occur? We checked out fashions that might work in a scenario the place typical automobiles and automatic automobiles might be sharing the highway, since you want the insurance coverage resolution to work for each.

And that’s what the one insurance coverage coverage permits. It makes certain that individuals have entry to truthful and fast compensation, and it could actually coexist with the present auto insurance coverage insurance policies for typical automobiles.

Automated automobiles and autonomous automobiles are an instance of a expertise the place growth is outpacing the regulatory setting. What can insurers do in these circumstances to guarantee that they’re up to the mark, whereas additionally not investing in one thing that may simply be hype and never actuality?

From a public coverage perspective, it’s about participating the federal government, participating regulators and speaking about these points. Speaking in regards to the significance of learning the insurance coverage legal guidelines and rules and ensuring that they’re applicable. At IBC, we’re making an attempt to make that occur, however corporations can try this individually too.

We’ve spent a whole lot of time speaking in regards to the single insurance coverage coverage and the data-sharing piece. However what’s vital is that it’s much less about these two options and extra about governments and regulators this challenge, and inspecting the insurance coverage legal guidelines to guarantee that they’re applicable in a world the place automobiles are automated.

We expect that the answer that we’ve placed on the desk is a very good one. However earlier than even getting there we need to be having these discussions intimately with the governments trying on the insurance coverage legal guidelines, and if a greater resolution comes out of it, we’re all ears on that. However actually we need to be having that dialogue the place we’ve got the insurance coverage business, the provincial governments, and the regulators trying on the insurance coverage legal guidelines, and ensuring they’re applicable in an automatic car world.

Nice. And doubtless an excellent coverage to be having as we take a look at different improvements that which can be coming into our society as nicely. And other people can obtain your paper off the web site, is that appropriate?

They will. It’s accessible on our web site.

Excellent. And thanks very a lot for making the time to talk to us. This was a very attention-grabbing dialog.

It was my pleasure.


On this episode of the Accenture Insurance coverage Influencers podcast, we talked about:

  • IBC survey findings that normally, folks understand self-driving vehicles as safer than typical vehicles.
  • Why it’s vital for insurers to proactively have interaction governments and regulators on points like self-driving vehicles, to make sure that insurance coverage coverage is supplied to cope with real-life danger.
  • Guiding ideas for updating legal guidelines for brand spanking new applied sciences and tendencies—particularly, that injured events should have entry to truthful and fast compensation.

For extra steerage on self-driving vehicles:

That wraps up our interviews with Ryan Stein. For those who loved this sequence, take a look at our subsequent visitor. Lex Sokolin is a futurist and fintech entrepreneur, and he spoke with us about how expertise and digital are upending the established order in monetary companies. We additionally talked about synthetic intelligence (AI)—the way it’s totally different from automation, the way it can rework the insurance coverage worth chain and why AI bias is so insidious.

What to do subsequent:

Contact us in case you’d prefer to be a visitor on the Insurance coverage Influencers podcast.

Related Articles


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Latest Articles